Talk to Us: (877) 225-8978
Product & Innovation

Why Empathetic Candidate Rejection Letters Matter

You can’t hire everyone you interview, but how you handle the process of rejecting candidates can have wide-ranging impacts on your business. See why empathetic rejection letters are important for your business.
The modern job market is a cutthroat competition for securing top-quality talent, and how you manage the hiring process can make all the difference. You can’t hire everyone you interview. A vast majority of people who apply to your company will be rejected. How you handle that process can make a massive difference for both your company and for the people who applied to your job. Empathetic candidate rejection letters are a vital part of any company’s hiring process.  These letters are your opportunity to showcase your company’s values, create lasting impressions, and build relationships with potential future hires. With a thoughtful and empathetic approach to rejection letters, you can cultivate a positive employer brand and nurture a talent pipeline that will pay dividends in the long run. In certain industries, how you handle a rejection letter can have wide-ranging impacts. Jennifer Staats, owner/manager of Staats Solutions, says this is extremely important in the Real Estate industry, “Rejecting a candidate in the wrong way can lead to future issues as candidates could either be on the other side of a deal in the future or a potential client.” In this article, we’ll explore their importance, share tips on crafting the perfect letter, and reveal how a well-written rejection email can open doors to opportunities you never knew existed.  Get ready to transform your hiring process and leave a lasting impression on every candidate who crosses your path.

The importance of empathy in a candidate rejection letter

Convey empathy in rejection emails to maintain a positive candidate experience

Job seekers invest significant time and effort in the application process.  As a hiring manager or business owner, it is crucial to acknowledge this by conveying empathy in your rejection emails.  This helps maintain a positive candidate experience and leaves the door open for future interactions with your company.

Empathetic language in candidate rejection email templates

Using empathetic language in your candidate rejection email template shows that your company cares about the applicant’s feelings. This can include expressing gratitude for the candidate’s interest and acknowledging the time and effort they put into applying.
  • Address the candidate by their name to create a personal connection 
  • Thank the candidate for their interest in the job and for considering your company
  • Recognize the time and energy candidates spent on their application
  • Adopt a compassionate tone to convey understanding, kindness, and empathy
  • Provide words of encouragement to keep candidates motivated in their job search
“One way to be encouraging to a candidate is to tell them something specific that you liked from your interview with them,” Staats says.

Strengthen employer brand through compassionate candidate rejection letters

A well-crafted, empathetic rejection letter can help strengthen your employer brand by showcasing your company’s commitment to treating applicants with respect and kindness. This reflects positively on your company culture and can encourage top talent to apply in the future.

Improve reviews on social media and employer review websites

Negative candidate experiences can lead to poor reviews on social media and employer review websites, harming your company’s reputation.  By sending compassionate rejection emails, you can reduce the likelihood of such negative reviews and maintain a positive image.

How to craft a clear and transparent rejection letter

Providing specific reasons for rejection to assist candidates in their job search

Offering clear and specific reasons for a candidate’s rejection can be helpful for their ongoing job search. This demonstrates transparency and helps applicants understand how they can improve in future applications.

Maintaining transparency in rejection emails for better candidate understanding

Transparency in rejection emails can lead to better candidate understanding and acceptance of the decision. By being honest and clear about the reasons for rejection, you show candidates that you respect their time and effort.

Striking a balance between clarity and brevity in rejection letters

Rejection emails should be concise, yet clear. Striking a balance between providing sufficient information and keeping the message brief ensures that candidates can quickly understand the reasons for their rejection without feeling overwhelmed by excessive detail. Staats says you should let a candidate know why it wasn’t a good fit for the long term, but you shouldn’t go into too much detail either.

The importance of timely communication in candidate rejection emails

Prompt communication is essential when sending rejection emails. Timely responses show respect for the candidate’s time and effort, while delayed responses can leave candidates uncertain and frustrated.

Benefits of a well-crafted rejection email template 

  1. Save time: With a pre-written template, you can quickly and efficiently send rejection emails without starting from scratch each time.
  2. Uniform messaging: A template ensures that all candidates receive a consistent message reflecting your company’s values and culture.
  3. Maintain a professional image: A well-crafted template helps maintain a professional image using polished language and a clear format.
  4. Minimize errors: Using a template reduces the chance of errors, such as typos or misinformation, that could damage your employer brand.
  5. Customize for each use: A template can be easily tailored to suit each candidate by personalizing the salutation and including specific feedback.
Utilizing a well-crafted rejection email template, like the one we have for you here, can make a significant difference in consistency and professionalism in your hiring process.  It helps ensure that every candidate receives a rejection email with a similar tone and structure, creating a positive experience for all applicants.

How to Provide Constructive Feedback in Rejection Emails

When crafting a candidate rejection email, it’s entirely understandable to want to spare their feelings – but skimping on constructive feedback can do more harm than good. If a candidate made it further along in the process but didn’t get the final offer, they would benefit from some specific feedback. 

The benefits of offering constructive feedback in candidate rejection letters

Providing constructive feedback in rejection emails can:
  • Help candidates improve their skills and application strategies
  • Foster a positive candidate experience
  • Demonstrate your company is invested in their growth and development
  • Build trust and a stronger employer brand

Tips for providing actionable advice without overstepping boundaries

Focus on job-related aspects: Keep feedback centered on the candidate’s skills, experience, or qualifications directly relevant to the job requirements. Be objective and specific: Offer clear and objective feedback, pointing out specific examples from the candidate’s application or interview performance that can be improved upon. Offer guidance, not directives: Phrase your suggestions as guidance rather than commands, using language like “you might consider” or “it could be helpful to” instead of “you must” or “you should.” Keep it balanced: While pointing out improvement areas, acknowledge the candidate’s strengths to maintain a positive tone. Respect boundaries: Avoid giving feedback on personal traits or characteristics irrelevant to the job, and never delve into personal or sensitive topics. It may seem like a small gesture, but providing constructive feedback can leave a lasting impact and make a difference in someone’s career journey.

Leveraging Rejection Emails to Build a Talent Pipeline

Every rejection letter presents a unique opportunity. It’s not just saying “thanks, but no thanks” and moving on to the next candidate.  With the right approach, a rejection letter can be the beginning of a long-term relationship with talented individuals. In fact, a genuinely respectful, compassionate, and encouraging response could set the stage for future opportunities.

Transform rejected candidates into potential future hires 

A well-crafted rejection letter can leave a lasting impression on rejected candidates, transforming them into potential future hires. By maintaining a positive relationship, you create a pool of talent that you can tap into when new opportunities arise.

Develop relationships through meaningful rejection emails

Rejection emails offer an opportunity to develop relationships with candidates, even if they do not fit the current job opening. You can nurture these relationships and maintain ongoing communication by being empathetic, transparent, and offering constructive feedback.

Encourage ongoing communication and networking 

Using rejection emails as a platform for networking can help build a robust talent pipeline for future job openings. Encourage candidates to stay connected with your company on social media, sign up for job alerts, and attend relevant events or webinars. 

Building a talent pipeline to reduce future hiring costs and efforts

By leveraging rejection emails to build a talent pipeline, you can reduce future hiring costs and efforts. A pool of vetted candidates can shorten the time to fill open positions and decrease the resources required for the recruitment process.

The lasting impact of quality candidate rejection letters

Crafting thoughtful and empathetic candidate rejection letters is vital in today’s fiercely competitive job market.  Quality candidate rejection letters not only demonstrate respect for applicants but also have the power to create a positive employer brand and establish lasting relationships with potential future hires. By embracing empathy, transparency, and professionalism in your rejection letters, you’ll ensure your company stands out in the ever-evolving world of work. How you handle the hiring process can leave a lasting impression on candidates and impact your company’s success.  Implementing the strategies we’ve discussed and utilizing tools like Wizehire to streamline your hiring process, you’ll be well on your way to creating a memorable candidate experience that resonates with top talent.  So, be bold and take the initiative to transform your hiring process, and watch as your company reaps the tremendous benefits of having an outstanding employer brand.  Your candidates, team, and company will thank you for it! Click here to see a candidate rejection letter template.


Chris Grubbs

Find your people. Grow your team. Meet your Wizehire.