The Case for Strategic Hiring — Live Webinar — Thursday, Dec 5 at 1 PM EST

People Management

Employee Performance Review Checklists 

Employee performance reviews are a critical part of effective performance management. When done well, they provide a structured way to assess individual contributions, give constructive feedback, and support employee development. This guide provides a deep dive into running an impactful performance review process from start to finish.

What Is an Employee Performance Review?

A performance review is a formal assessment in which managers evaluate an employee’s work performance, identify relevant strengths and weaknesses, offer constructive feedback for skill development, and assist with goal setting. 

The two primary goals are:

  1. deliver an accurate and actionable evaluation of the employee’s performance
  2. develop that person’s skills in line with current and future job requirements

Onboarding and beyond

Springboard your team’s success from the start with our growing toolbox of onboarding solutions.

blog-cta-image-real-estate

There are several different types of performance review examples, including:

  • annual performance reviews
  • quarterly performance evaluations
  • monthly performance check-ins
  • weekly one-on-one meetings
  • project-based reviews
  • 360-degree feedback from multiple sources (peers, direct reports, clients)

The right mix depends on your organization’s needs, but it’s generally best to use a combination of regular check-ins supplemented by formal reviews. Regardless of format, the spirit of the review should be future-focused and centered on promoting employee growth and development.

Why Are Performance Reviews Important?

Effective performance reviews are a powerful tool for driving both individual and organizational success. Key benefits include:

  • aligning individual roles and responsibilities to broader business goals 
  • clarifying job expectations and setting employees up for success 
  • providing employees with regular, constructive feedback on their performances 
  • identifying development goals and career paths 
  • motivating employees by demonstrating their contributions are valued 
  • enabling recognition and rewards for strong performance

By tying individual performance to organizational objectives, reviews keep everyone working toward a shared vision of success. Managers can also use them to help inform an employee’s performance improvement plan and promote improved interpersonal skills in the workplace.

How to Conduct a Great Performance Review

Delivering a meaningful, growth-oriented review conversation requires advance planning. Key steps include:

Schedule ample meeting time and minimize distractions

Gather and review relevant input, such as the employee’s self-evaluation, peer feedback, and job description

Prepare specific feedback with examples of strengths and areas for development

Ask the employee to come ready to share their perspectives and questions

Discuss top priorities and co-create SMART goals to work towards before the next review

During the conversation, focus on behaviors and outcomes rather than personality traits. Share feedback with empathy and position it as an opportunity for growth. Actively seek the employee’s input and be open to their feedback as well. 

How to Build a Successful Employee Experience Strategy

Job seekers prioritize employee experience when searching for a new role. A comprehensive employee experience strategy can help your organization…

Performance Review Criteria Examples

Specific evaluation criteria will vary based on the role, level, and organization; however, most performance reviews typically cover the following:

  • Goals, performance, and results
  • Demonstration of company values and culture
  • Job-specific skills and competencies
  • Behavioral skills like collaboration, communication, and problem-solving
  • Compliance with policies and procedures

To ensure a well-rounded assessment, gather input from multiple sources, including the employee’s self-evaluation, peer and client feedback, and your observations.

How to Phrase Things Carefully in a Performance Review

When delivering feedback, avoid generic phrases in favor of specific guidance. For example:

Instead of: “You had a great year! Let’s aim even higher next quarter.”

Try: “Your work on the ABC project exceeded expectations and demonstrated strong project management skills. For the next quarter, I’d like to see you take on a stretch assignment to continue developing your capabilities in this area.”

Effective performance reviews require careful communication. Here’s what to embrace and avoid:

Embrace:

  • Using specific behavioral examples: “Your presentation to the client last month effectively addressed their concerns and led to a 20% increase in our contract value.”
  • Focusing on actions and outcomes: “By implementing the new inventory system, you’ve reduced stockouts by 30% this quarter.”
  • Providing balanced feedback: “While your technical skills are strong, there’s an opportunity to improve your project management abilities.”
  • Using “I” statements: “I’ve noticed that you consistently meet deadlines, which greatly contributes to the team’s success.”

Avoid:

  • Using absolutes like “always” or “never”: These are rarely accurate and can put employees on the defensive.
  • Making personal attacks: Focus on performance, not personality.
  • Comparing employees to each other: This can create resentment and is not constructive.
  • Using vague praise or criticism: “Good job” or “needs improvement” without specifics is not helpful.

Examples of effective phrasing:

Instead of: “You’re not a team player.”

Say: “I’ve observed that you often work independently on projects. How can we find more opportunities for you to collaborate with the team?”

Instead of: “Your work is sloppy.”

Say: “I’ve noticed some inconsistencies in your reports. Let’s discuss some strategies to enhance the accuracy and presentation of your work.”

Instead of: “You need to be more proactive.”

Say: “I’d like to see you take more initiative in identifying and addressing potential issues before they escalate. Can we brainstorm some ways to achieve this?”

Remember, the goal is to provide specific, actionable feedback that’s focused on future improvement. By phrasing feedback carefully and constructively, managers can turn performance reviews into powerful tools for employee development and organizational success.

How to Prepare for a Performance Review

When prepping for a performance review, use these tips to set the right tone for a constructive two-way dialogue:

Schedule the meeting at least two weeks in advance

Ask the employee to complete a self-evaluation and come prepared with questions

Write out your feedback, citing specific examples

Draft an agenda covering past performance and future goals

Allow ample time for the employee to respond and add to the discussion

The most productive reviews feel more like a conversation than a top-down evaluation. Approach it with a spirit of curiosity and a genuine desire to understand the employee’s experience and support their continued growth.

How to Write a Performance Review

Writing an effective performance review requires careful preparation and thoughtful composition. Here are key steps to follow: 

Gather relevant information

Review the employee’s job description

Collect performance data and metrics

Consider feedback from colleagues and clients

Review past performance reviews and goals

Candidate texting from Wizehire

Boost your open rates by up to 97% and reduce no-shows by as much as 71%.

wizehire-candidate-texting-1024x772

Start with a clear structure

Introduction summarizing overall performance

Detailed assessment of key performance areas

Discussion of strengths and achievements

Areas for improvement and development

Future goals and objectives

Use Specific Examples

Cite concrete instances of performance, both positive and areas for growth

Quantify achievements where possible (e.g., “increased sales by 15%”)

Be Objective and Balanced

Avoid personal biases

Provide a mix of positive feedback and constructive criticism

Other Considerations

Discuss actions and results rather than personality traits

Use clear, professional language

Avoid jargon or overly complex terms

Be direct but tactful in addressing areas for improvement

Include actionable feedback

Offer specific suggestions for improvement

Outline steps for skill development

Leave space for the employee’s self-assessment and comments

Ensure the review is clear, concise, and free of errors

Remember, the written review should serve as a basis for a productive face-to-face discussion, not a substitute for it. Use it as a tool to promote a healthier company culture and guide meaningful conversations about performance and development.

Cementing Progress After the Performance Review

The performance review is a critical milestone, but it’s not the end of the road. Sustaining progress requires an ongoing effort from both manager and employee:

Provide the employee with a written summary of their review

Have them formally acknowledge receipt and add their comments

Schedule regular 1:1s to check on goal progress and maintain alignment

Look for opportunities to provide coaching and real-time feedback

Recognize and celebrate incremental wins along the way

Performance management works best as a continuous dialogue, not a once-a-year event. By adopting a future-focused, employee-centric approach to reviews, you can transform them from a dreaded chore into a meaningful tool for driving individual and organizational success.

Wize Words

Employee performance reviews provide a powerful opportunity to acknowledge contributions, fuel employee development, and drive organizational alignment and results.

By positioning reviews as a two-way growth dialogue, you can boost employee motivation, productivity, and retention—all of which are essential for business success.

Author

  • ryan-lawrence

    Ryan Lawrence is a highly experienced HR writer who’s spent two decades covering diverse workplace topics for small- and mid-size businesses. With a keen eye for detail, he delves into the complexities of human resources, focusing on the trends impacting the workplace and giving HR professionals actionable solutions.

    View all posts Writer
The article was reviewed by Courtney Woods

Ryan Lawrence

Ryan Lawrence is a highly experienced HR writer who’s spent two decades covering diverse workplace topics for small- and mid-size businesses. With a keen eye for detail, he delves into the complexities of human resources, focusing on the trends impacting the workplace and giving HR professionals actionable solutions.

Find your people.
Grow your team.
Meet your Wizehire.