Table of Contents
What is Decentralized Hiring?
Decentralized hiring is a recruitment approach where the responsibility for hiring is distributed across various departments or locations within a company, rather than being managed solely by a central HR or recruitment team. In this model, department heads, managers, or even teams in different regions have the authority to recruit and hire for their specific needs.
Example: A national law firm has offices in several major cities across the country. While the firm’s headquarters sets overall hiring policies, recruitment is decentralized to each office to accommodate regional needs and legal specialties.
Everything you need to grow your team, all in one place.
This approach allows businesses to:
- Make faster hiring decisions by empowering managers closer to the role to oversee the process.
- Tailor recruitment efforts to meet the specific needs of each department or location.
- Increase flexibility by letting different parts of the business adjust hiring strategies based on local market conditions or team dynamics.
However, decentralized hiring can lead to inconsistencies in hiring practices if not properly coordinated, which is why many organizations still provide centralized guidance or use standardized tools to support decentralized hiring efforts.
Centralized vs. Decentralized Hiring
These different structures result in two very different approaches to finding new talent.
In decentralized hiring, individual departments or locations handle recruitment, offering flexibility and faster hiring decisions. However, this can lead to inconsistencies and less oversight in ensuring adherence to company-wide policies.
In centralized hiring, a central HR team manages the entire recruitment process, ensuring consistency and compliance across the organization. This approach creates a uniform candidate experience but can be slower due to decision-making bottlenecks.
Centralized hiring brings consistency to the process, creating a smoother experience for candidates. Data from the CandE Benchmark Research program shows that companies with decentralized hiring have a 19% candidate resentment rate, compared to a much lower 13% for teams with centralized recruitment.
The Challenges of Decentralized Hiring
Decentralized hiring offers the flexibility to meet local needs, but it also comes with its own set of challenges.
Increased Complexity
Managing hiring efforts across multiple locations or departments introduces additional layers of complexity, particularly in terms of communication and coordination.
Different teams may use various tools and platforms to manage the hiring process, making it harder to share insights or data across the company. Ensuring alignment with overall organizational goals while maintaining efficiency can be a logistical challenge in a decentralized model.
Inconsistent Processes
In a decentralized hiring model, each department or location may develop its own way of recruiting, interviewing, and selecting candidates. This lack of standardization can lead to variations in the candidate experience, making it harder to ensure that each hire is evaluated fairly and consistently across the organization. These inconsistencies can also complicate measuring the effectiveness of the hiring process at a company-wide level.
Reduced Oversight
When hiring is managed locally, there’s less centralized control over how the process is executed. This can lead to situations where company-wide policies, such as diversity initiatives or legal compliance requirements, are overlooked or inconsistently applied.
Ensuring that all locations adhere to essential hiring standards becomes more difficult without a centralized system in place to monitor and enforce these policies.
Quality Control
In decentralized hiring, local teams or managers may prioritize speed over thoroughness, leading to potential mismatches between the company’s values and the candidates being hired. Ensuring that all new hires meet company standards for both skills and cultural fit can be challenging without a consistent, organization-wide approach to candidate assessment.
Solutions to Organize Your Decentralized Hiring Process
Overcoming the challenges of decentralized hiring requires strong communication, appropriate tools, and occasional centralized oversight to ensure that company-wide goals and standards are met. Here are some solutions that can help organize your decentralized hiring efforts:
Standardize Hiring Guidelines
Implement clear, company-wide hiring guidelines that outline best practices for recruitment, interviewing, and candidate evaluation. Providing templates for job descriptions, interview questions, and candidate scoring ensures that all locations or departments follow a consistent process, while still allowing flexibility to meet local needs.
Use a Hiring Platform
Many of today’s human resources (HR) professionals use automated technology—like hiring platforms, applicant tracking systems, and onboarding tools—to make the recruitment process more efficient. With a single platform, local managers can track applicants, communicate with candidates, and collaborate with other hiring teams, all while maintaining a uniform process that adheres to company standards.
Provide Regular Training
Equip local managers and hiring teams with training on effective recruitment practices, legal compliance, and company policies. Regular workshops can empower decentralized hiring managers to make informed decisions while staying aligned with company standards. This information can also be included in an employee handbook for employees to reference.
Use Data to Monitor and Improve
Track key hiring metrics, such as time to hire, cost per hire, and candidate satisfaction, across all locations. This data can help you identify areas for improvement, ensure consistency, and maintain a high-quality candidate experience across the board.
Take a Flexible Approach to Talent Management
In a decentralized hiring structure, prospective employees typically apply for a role in a specific location or department, without much room for lateral movement.
Instead, consider a more flexible approach when employees have the opportunity to transfer to different locations or teams. This gives employees more flexibility and potential for growth based on their skill sets. A flexible talent management strategy can also help you keep your most important roles filled to improve productivity.
Wize Words
Organizing a decentralized hiring process doesn’t have to be complicated. With clear guidelines and the right tools, you can maintain consistency while allowing local teams the flexibility they need.
Author
Share
See How It Works